Smart Asset
Helping people make smart financial decisions
7 of the Biggest Roth Conversion Mistakes
Are you making any of these common Roth Conversion mistakes?
Take Retirement QuizFind up to three advisors who serve your area, free!
Roth conversions can be an effective strategy for optimizing retirement savings, but they come with potential pitfalls.
Converting pre-tax retirement accounts such as IRAs to after-tax Roth IRAs could allow you to keep growing funds tax-free and then make withdrawals in retirement without paying taxes.
But is this the right retirement savings strategy for you? To find out, it could be a good idea to speak with a financial advisor.
Consulting a fiduciary financial advisor can be a great first step to weighing a Roth conversion, the potential tax repercussions, and how it could fit into your overall retirement plan. That's why SmartAsset created a free tool to help match you with up to three financial advisors.
Click here to take SmartAsset’s quick retirement quiz and get matched with vetted advisors in just a few minutes, each obligated to work in your best interest.
Research suggests people who work with a financial advisor feel more at ease about their finances and could end up with about 15% more money to spend in retirement.1
A 2022 Northwestern Mutual study found that 62% of U.S. adults admit their financial planning needs improvement. However, only 35% of Americans work with a financial advisor.2
Here are seven of the most common mistakes to avoid when considering a Roth conversion.
Smart Financial Tools
7 of the Biggest Roth Conversion Mistakes
1. Ignoring the Tax Impact
One of the most significant errors in a Roth conversion can be not fully accounting for the immediate tax consequences.
When you convert a traditional IRA to a Roth IRA, the converted amount is considered taxable income you must pay taxes on in the tax year of the conversion. Miscalculating this could lead to an unexpected and potentially hefty tax bill, which might push you into a higher tax bracket for the year.
2. Not Considering Future Tax Rates
The primary advantage of a Roth IRA is that withdrawals are tax-free in retirement.
However, if you anticipate being in a lower tax bracket in retirement than you are now, the conversion may not be as beneficial. It can be important to project your future income and tax scenario to make an informed decision.
This is something a financial advisor could help with.
3. Converting Too Much at Once
Many individuals may make the mistake of converting large sums all at once.
This approach could potentially lead to a significant tax burden in a single year. Instead, spreading the conversion over several years may help manage the tax impact and potentially avoid pushing yourself into a higher tax bracket. This strategy could require careful planning and timing to optimize tax efficiency.
4. Overlooking the Five-Year Rule
Roth IRAs have a five-year rule requiring you to wait five years after the conversion before you can withdraw the earnings tax-free.
If not, you might face taxes and potential penalties on the withdrawn earnings. This rule applies to each conversion separately, so it can be important to keep track of the timing for each conversion to avoid potential costly mistakes .
5. Neglecting State Taxes
While federal taxes are a primary concern, many may forget to consider state taxes in their Roth conversion strategy.
States have different rules regarding Roth conversions, and some may impose additional taxes. Neglecting this could potentially result in unexpected state tax liabilities, diminishing the overall benefits of the conversion.
6. Not Coordinating with Social Security Benefits
A Roth conversion could also impact how your Social Security benefits are taxed.
If the conversion increases your income significantly, it may cause a larger portion of your Social Security benefits to be taxed. Be sure to understand how the conversion could affect your overall financial situation, including Social Security, to avoid potential unintended consequences.
7. Failing to Account for Medicare Surcharges
Higher income from a Roth conversion can also lead to increased Medicare premiums due to Income-Related Monthly Adjustment Amounts (IRMAA).
If your modified adjusted gross income (MAGI) exceeds certain thresholds, you may have to pay higher premiums for Medicare Part B and Part D. This additional cost could potentially erode the potential benefits of a Roth conversion.
How to Get Help With a Roth Conversion
Navigating a Roth conversion may require careful planning and a thorough understanding of your current and future financial situation. By avoiding these common mistakes, you could help maximize the potential benefits and help ensure a smoother transition to tax-free retirement income.
Deciding whether or not to convert regular IRA assets to a Roth IRA could call for careful evaluation of your financial and tax situation. That’s where a financial advisor can be invaluable.
Fiduciaries may be able to help you understand your options when it comes to planning for Roth conversions and minimizing your tax liability. Additionally, any conflicts of interest must be disclosed, and fiduciaries are obligated to work in your best interest.
Finding a fiduciary shouldn't be that hard. Thankfully, now it isn't.
SmartAsset’s free matching quiz can match you with up to three fiduciary advisors who serve your area. From there, you can compare and decide which advisor to work with. All advisors on the matching platform have been vetted through our proprietary due diligence process.
The quiz takes just a few minutes, and in many cases, you can be connected instantly with an advisor to have an introductory call.
Click Your State to Get Matched With Financial Advisors Who Serve Your Area
After you choose your state and answer a few questions, you can compare up to three advisors that serve your area and decide which to work with.
Find up to three advisors who serve your area, free!